2011

Click here to read the letter.

🧠 Key Takeaways

  • What makes sense at one price might make absolutely no sense at another. Investors would be wise to pay attention to the price a company is paying for its own shares, rather than automatically treating buybacks as a form of "value creation" that can do no wrong.

  • Two important principles that any company implementing share buybacks should follow: Don't repurchase shares just to support the share price, and don't sacrifice your balance sheet to do it.

  • If you own a business that's actively buying back its own stock, the ideal outcome is that the business continues growing for a long time, but its share price doesn't.

  • If you’re going to be a net buyer of stocks in the future, you should actually rejoice when share prices go down. This especially true if nothing about the underlying businesses has changed.

  • When a stock's share price starts going up, it can become more attractive to other investors who see that appreciation as validation of the investment. That causes them to jump in and start buying shares themselves, which pushes the share price even higher and attracts more investors who want to hop on the bandwagon. Eventually, the appreciation itself becomes the main reason people are investing, rather than anything having to do with the underlying value or fundamentals of what they're buying.

  • If a bubble has formed, it will eventually pop. Nobody knows exactly when that will happen, but when it does, the investors who came late to the party are often the ones most negatively impacted.

  • People will always need and want things. Regardless of what form currency takes in the future, people will continue to trade what they earn for things that other people produce. Consumer demand is timeless. The trick, though, is that if you're going to invest in consumer products, you want to find businesses selling products that are also timeless.

  • One of the most tried-and-true investing strategies is to own high-quality, fundamentally strong businesses that seem poised to get bigger and better over time. Although there are many ways to do so, you don't need to overcomplicate it beyond that.


✍️ Memorable Quotes

“We have witnessed many bouts of repurchasing that failed our second test. Sometimes, of course, infractions - even serious ones - are innocent; many CEOs never stop believing their stock is cheap. In other instances, a less benign conclusion seems warranted. It doesn’t suffice to say that repurchases are being made to offset the dilution from stock issuances or simply because a company has excess cash. Continuing shareholders are hurt unless shares are purchased below intrinsic value. The first law of capital allocation - whether the money is slated for acquisitions or share repurchases - is that what is smart at one price is dumb at another. (One CEO who always stresses the price/value factor in repurchase decisions is Jamie Dimon at J.P. Morgan; I recommend that you read his annual letter.)”

In the eyes of many investors, buying back shares is never a bad idea (especially when the alternative is paying out a dividend — yuck!).

But Warren adds some nuance here. Share buybacks are just another tool that companies can use for the benefit of their shareholders. And like any other tool, there are times when it makes sense to use it and times when it doesn't.

Warren has written about this in other letters as well, but generally speaking, the best time for a company to buy back its own shares is when those shares are trading for less than they're intrinsically worth.

It's really no different than making an acquisition. In both cases, you're allocating capital to purchase ownership in a business, and you don't want to overpay for what you're buying.

However, many investors don't even consider the price at which a company is buying back its shares, and many companies seem to approach buybacks the same way. They just see buybacks as a good thing, regardless of valuation.

The problem is that buying back shares at too high a price can ultimately hurt the shareholders who stay invested in the business. Instead of creating value, the company could actually be destroying it by spending more money on those shares than they're worth.

That's why Warren writes that what makes sense at one price might make absolutely no sense at another. Investors would be wise to pay attention to the price a company is paying for its own shares, rather than automatically treating buybacks as a form of "value creation" that can do no wrong.

“At our limit price of 110% of book value, repurchases clearly increase Berkshire’s per-share intrinsic value. And the more and the cheaper we buy, the greater the gain for continuing shareholders. Therefore, if given the opportunity, we will likely repurchase stock aggressively at our price limit or lower. You should know, however, that we have no interest in supporting the stock and that our bids will fade in particularly weak markets. Nor will we buy shares if our cash-equivalent holdings are below $20 billion. At Berkshire, financial strength that is unquestionable takes precedence over all else.”

Continuing on from the previous quote, Warren adds some more color to how they approach share buybacks at Berkshire.

One important distinction here is that Warren explicitly states that they have no interest in buying back shares just to prop up Berkshire's share price. Other companies might do that, but that can conflict with the long-term interests of shareholders if they're buying back shares at overvalued prices.

Additionally, Warren makes it clear that they won't repurchase shares if doing so would put Berkshire's financial strength in a questionable position. Even if the shares are attractively valued, they won't buy them if doing so would reduce their cash reserves below a certain level.

Ultimately, I think these are two important principles that any company implementing share buybacks should follow: Don't repurchase shares just to support the share price, and don't sacrifice your balance sheet to do it.

Any company that ignores those principles is providing an example of what not to do.

“This discussion of repurchases offers me the chance to address the irrational reaction of many investors to changes in stock prices. When Berkshire buys stock in a company that is repurchasing shares, we hope for two events: First, we have the normal hope that earnings of the business will increase at a good clip for a long time to come; and second, we also hope that the stock underperforms in the market for a long time as well. A corollary to this second point: “Talking our book” about a stock we own - were that to be effective - would actually be harmful to Berkshire, not helpful as commentators customarily assume.”

When Berkshire owns shares of a business that's actively buying back its own stock, the ideal outcome is that the business continues growing for a long time, but its share price doesn't.

That might sound a bit counterintuitive, as Warren points out in the opening of the quote, but it makes sense when you think about it. If you're going to be buying something, especially a business that continues to fundamentally grow, you're much better off buying it for as low a price as possible.

And in this case, it's not just Berkshire that's doing the buying. The company itself is also repurchasing shares, which means lower share prices allow it to retire more shares for the same amount of money. That increases Berkshire's percentage ownership of the business without Berkshire having to invest another dollar.

This is the opposite of what most investors want, though. They want to buy a stock and immediately see it go up.

That might make them feel good, but that premature appreciation makes it more expensive for both Berkshire and the company itself to accumulate shares. And when it comes to owning cash-flowing businesses, the amount of ownership you accumulate matters a lot.

Adding to this point, Warren also touches on the impact that revealing his investments might have. Many commentators assume that talking publicly about the stocks Berkshire owns would be beneficial, since Warren has enough juice that the mere knowledge of his ownership could push the share price higher.

But as Warren explains, that would actually be detrimental to Berkshire. A higher share price means the company can't repurchase as many shares for the same amount of money, which reduces the benefit to Berkshire as a continuing shareholder.

“The logic is simple: If you are going to be a net buyer of stocks in the future, either directly with your own money or indirectly (through your ownership of a company that is repurchasing shares), you are hurt when stocks rise. You benefit when stocks swoon. Emotions, however, too often complicate the matter: Most people, including those who will be net buyers in the future, take comfort in seeing stock prices advance. These shareholders resemble a commuter who rejoices after the price of gas increases, simply because his tank contains a day’s supply.”

If you were buying a t-shirt, groceries, or gas (we especially feel that one lately), you would obviously be happy to spend less money to buy the exact same thing.

But this is one of the counterintuitive things about investing. When share prices go down, that same rule of thumb doesn’t apply. Instead of being happy that the stocks we own (and would like to own more of) are cheaper to buy, we typically feel upset or concerned.

To some extent, I think that reaction makes sense. When the share price of a stock you own goes down, it feels like you’re literally losing money.

Like Warren says though, if you’re going to be a net buyer of stocks in the future, you should actually rejoice when share prices go down. This especially true if nothing about the underlying businesses has changed.

Still, knowing that logically doesn’t necessarily make it any easier emotionally. When a stock drops below the price you paid for it, it’s hard not to feel like you made a bad decision buying when you did.

Loss aversion tells us that the pain of an unrealized loss hurts about twice as much as the same percentage gain would feel good. But you have to overcome that.

This speaks to one of the most difficult parts about investing, and that’s overcoming yourself and your innate human quirks. In your head, you might know that lower share prices are beneficial to you as a chronic buyer, but in your stomach, you feel the opposite.

If you can learn to look beyond what the share price is doing today and instead focus on the opportunity that lower prices are offering you for the benefit of the future, then hopefully you can learn to find the bright side in the downside.

“What motivates most gold purchasers is their belief that the ranks of the fearful will grow. During the past decade that belief has proved correct. Beyond that, the rising price has on its own generated additional buying enthusiasm, attracting purchasers who see the rise as validating an investment thesis. As ‘bandwagon’ investors join any party, they create their own truth - for a while.”

What's most interesting to me about this quote is the enthusiasm that followed gold's rising price. This phenomenon isn't exclusive to gold, either. It's something we commonly see in the stock market as well.

When a stock's share price starts going up, it can become more attractive to other investors who see that appreciation as validation of the investment. That causes them to jump in and start buying shares themselves, which pushes the share price even higher and attracts more investors who want to hop on the bandwagon.

It becomes this self-reinforcing cycle where higher prices attract more buyers, and those additional buyers push prices even higher. Eventually, the appreciation itself becomes the main reason people are investing, rather than anything having to do with the underlying value or fundamentals of what they're buying.

If this goes on long enough, it can ultimately create a bubble, which can form in gold, an individual stock, or even the market as a whole. Generally speaking, though, what Warren is describing here is the kind of investor psychology that can help create one.

“Over the past 15 years, both Internet stocks and houses have demonstrated the extraordinary excesses that can be created by combining an initially sensible thesis with well-publicized rising prices. In these bubbles, an army of originally skeptical investors succumbed to the ‘proof’ delivered by the market, and the pool of buyers - for a time - expanded sufficiently to keep the bandwagon rolling. But bubbles blown large enough inevitably pop. And then the old proverb is confirmed once again: ‘What the wise man does in the beginning, the fool does in the end.’”

Even an investor with relatively little experience can spot a popular trend in the market — whether it's SPACs, electric vehicles, nuclear energy, or the “AI trade” of today.

Most of the time, there's actually a sensible investment thesis behind these trends. The problem, though, is that as more investors see the opportunity and pile in, prices can get carried away, and what started as a reasonable investment can turn into a bubble.

A sensible and discerning investor might recognize this early on and be cautious about participating, knowing that the excitement and momentum could eventually push prices much higher than what makes sense.

However, the longer these trends go on, the higher prices climb, and the more “proof” the market seems to deliver, the more difficult it becomes to stay away. Eventually, many investors who were originally skeptical of these trends give in to the temptation and hop on the bandwagon, not wanting to miss out any longer on the gains that everyone else has been getting.

And for a while, that works…until it doesn’t. If a bubble has formed, it will eventually pop. Nobody knows exactly when that will happen, but when it does, the investors who came late to the party are often the ones most negatively impacted.

“Whether the currency a century from now is based on gold, seashells, shark teeth, or a piece of paper (as today), people will be willing to exchange a couple of minutes of their daily labor for a Coca-Cola or some See’s peanut brittle. In the future the U.S. population will move more goods, consume more food, and require more living space than it does now. People will forever exchange what they produce for what others produce.”

There are a few things Warren touches on here that I think are important.

First and foremost, we get some insight into what he considers to be one of Coca-Cola's competitive advantages. Drinking a Coke has become such a habitual part of many consumers' lives, and it's affordable enough that they're willing to trade just a small portion of the money they earn through their labor to enjoy one.

Furthermore, Warren makes a broader point that people will always need and want things. Regardless of what form currency takes in the future, people will continue to trade what they earn for things that other people produce. Consumer demand is timeless.

The trick, though, is that if you're going to invest in consumer products, you want to find businesses selling products that are also timeless. Ideally, these are products built around deeply ingrained consumer habits that aren't likely to change — like enjoying Coca-Cola.

“Our country’s businesses will continue to efficiently deliver goods and services wanted by our citizens. Metaphorically, these commercial “cows” will live for centuries and give ever greater quantities of “milk” to boot. Their value will be determined not by the medium of exchange but rather by their capacity to deliver milk. Proceeds from the sale of the milk will compound for the owners of the cows, just as they did during the 20th century when the Dow increased from 66 to 11,497 (and paid loads of dividends as well). Berkshire’s goal will be to increase its ownership of first-class businesses. Our first choice will be to own them in their entirety - but we will also be owners by way of holding sizable amounts of marketable stocks. I believe that over any extended period of time this category of investing will prove to be the runaway winner among the three we’ve examined. More important, it will be by far the safest.”

Put simply, one of the most tried-and-true investing strategies is to own high-quality, fundamentally strong businesses that seem poised to get bigger and better over time.

In other words, buy businesses that have the ability to consistently grow their sales, profits, and free cash flow, share some of those profits with shareholders, and increase those distributions over time as the businesses themselves continue to grow.

Through this approach to investing, and given a long enough time horizon, you stand a very good chance of building substantial wealth. Although there are many ways to do so, you don't need to overcomplicate it beyond that.


Next
Next

2010