The Hidden Force Driving The Stock Market
Disclaimer: This page contains some affiliate links that might just lead you to the promised land of awesomeness (or at least some cool products). I may receive commissions for purchases made through links in this post.
As investors, we like to think of ourselves as logical people who approach every problem with rational, sound thinking. The thing about logical people, though, is that they try to come up with universal laws that can be applied to everyone, everywhere, all the time.
Now that kind of thinking might work in physics—Newton’s Third Law hasn’t changed in 300 years—but it doesn’t hold up when you add human beings into the equation.
Even though we try to be logical, we’re still people—and people are never perfect, precise, or predictable. We’re messy, chaotic, and often contradictory, which makes it impossible to come up with universal laws of human behavior.
These ideas come from a book I’m reading right now called Alchemy by Rory Sutherland. He has a quote in there that puts it all pretty well:
“Logic is what makes a successful engineer or mathematician, but psycho-logic is what has made us a successful breed of monkey that has survived and flourished over time. This alternative logic emerges from a parallel operating system within the human mind, which often operates unconsciously, and is far more powerful and pervasive than you realize. Rather like gravity, it is a force that nobody noticed until somebody put a name to it.”
The “alternative logic” he’s talking about is our built-in survival instincts. It’s not always conscious or rational, but it’s always there—running alongside reason as a parallel system in the brain.
Both are essential to our survival and development as a species. Rational logic helps us solve problems in the realms of things like physics and math, but that same logical part of the brain is pretty useless when you suddenly get thrown into fight-or-flight mode. That’s when this subconscious “psycho-logic” kicks in.
The thing is, this unconscious operating system is much more powerful (and much more commonly used) than we realize. We tend to focus on logic because it’s the part we can explain. But “psycho-logic” is the wizard behind the curtain, and it shapes our behavior without us even realizing it.
This mental power struggle works no differently in our portfolios. As I said earlier, we like to think we’re behaving out of pure logic when it comes to investing—analyze the data, run the discounted cash flow calculation, and the right answer will present itself.
But the stock market is not at all like Newton’s Third Law. It’s a complex system made up of people who are all making decisions driven just as much by our inherent “psycho-logic” as by spreadsheets.
That’s why stocks aren’t always priced where the numbers suggest they should, and it’s why the stock market will never be fully efficient. Things like fear, greed, FOMO, and status all play a role in influencing a stock’s share price, along with the underlying company’s earnings and free cash flow.
And like it or not, “psycho-logic” also shows up in dividend investing.
Even as dividend investors, I think we can all agree that dividends may not always be the most efficient use of capital on paper. But they feel safe, which offers some reassurance, and that makes them more attractive than logic alone can explain.
It’s kind of like paying off the mortgage on your house. A lot of people don’t think it makes sense on paper, but once again, are the numbers the only thing that matters in this instance? Might there be other benefits to paying off your mortgage that don’t show up in the numbers?
At the end of the day, the best investors don’t ignore logic, but they also don’t pretend that it’s the only thing that matters. If you can understand when “psycho-logic” is influencing certain companies or the market as a whole, you’ll be able to see opportunities others might miss.
And if you can design your portfolio in a way that works with your own “psycho-logic” rather than against it, you’ll actually be able to stick with investing long enough to reap the rewards.
With all of that said, now I want to hear from you: What’s one investment decision you’ve made that was driven more by “psycho-logic” than actual logic? Write to me here and let me know.
P.S. — If you want to see me review a few subscriber portfolios, I’m breaking down three of them here.
Dividend Investing Democratized
Join thousands of savvy investors in the pursuit of early retirement. Get Retire With Ryne delivered straight to your inbox every week as you build your perpetually growing, cash-flowing dividend stock portfolio.
Blossom is a unique social platform created by investors, for investors. Unlike the usual social media platforms, Blossom is dedicated exclusively to discussions on finance and investing.
I've been actively posting on Blossom for a few years now and I absolutely love the community on there. With over 400,000 DIY investors, Blossom is buzzing with all sorts of different investment ideas. The coolest part is that you can see everyone's full portfolios (including mine), which you can automatically link within the app!
Picture Twitter/X, but with an added portfolio tracking feature and less trolling – that's Blossom for you. Personally, I find it much more enjoyable than my experience on Twitter/X, and I think you will too.
Download Blossom today, and follow me (@ryne) to see my entire portfolio and stay updated on all my real-time investment moves.
IN MY PORTFOLIO 📈
Start tracking your portfolio with Snowball Analytics today—free for 14 days! Plus, use code "rynewilliams" at checkout to get 10% off your subscription.
ICYMI 🎥
Investing Is Changed Forever | Ep. 37
In this episode of The Deep End, we dive into why investing will never be the same again. From the rise of finance creators and retail investors to the growing pressure on Wall Street, we explore the financial revolution that’s unfolding right now.
CAREFULLY CURATED 🔍
📺 Prime P/E Ratio - In this video, PPC Ian takes a deep dive into a high-yield dividend stock that’s not just paying big, but also sitting at a bargain valuation with a P/E ratio of only about 4.5.
🎧 The Warren Buffett Way - In this episode of the Richer, Wiser, Happier podcast, William Green chats with Robert Hagstrom, who shares some of the powerful lessons he picked up from Warren Buffett, Charlie Munger, and Bill Miller.
📚 The Invisible Millions - In a world where false wealth shouts, true prosperity whispers. This article from Bogumil Baranowski explores the rise (and importance) of "quiet wealth."
SINCE YOU ASKED 💬
"Is it best to reinvest all your dividends for long-term compounding, and then stop reinvesting when you need the cash, like when you retire?"
- HazzeTy | YouTube
This is exactly how it should go. The general rule of thumb with dividends is to reinvest them unless you actually need the cash to pay bills or cover living expenses.
The reason for this is that dividends are a key component in the compounding equation. Your contributions, dividend raises, and reinvestments all work together to power the almighty dividend snowball.
Every dollar that goes back into buying more dividend-paying stocks—whether from your own contributions or from reinvested dividends—boosts your dividend income. And the more income you generate and reinvest, the more you’ll get paid in the next cycle. If you can avoid disrupting that process, you’ll reach financial freedom that much faster.
With that said, reinvesting your dividends doesn’t mean you automatically have to plow them back into the same stock that paid them. I personally collect my dividends as cash in my brokerage account and then manually reinvest them into whatever stock I want to buy at the time.
Either way, none of my dividends get spent. They all stay in my portfolio and keep compounding to generate even more income down the road.
Have a question? Ask me here to see it featured in an upcoming newsletter.
LAST WORD 👋
Over the past couple of months, I’ve been posting these short portfolio review videos on TikTok and YouTube (and all my social platforms, really). Basically, I’m reviewing portfolios from investors who have accounts on Blossom.
I’m putting these out almost every day, so if you’d like me to review your portfolio, all you have to do is set up a Blossom account and then send me a message with your username, or just tag me in a post.
It’s a fun way for us to connect, and it gives me a chance to share some personalized insights on your holdings.
